yousry.de/blog

If I’m asked to draw an “easy to understand” diagram about the next-generation architecture for Web-Applications, one of my sketches would look like this:

An obvious question about this picture is:

Why are two different Database-Systems necessary?

My artless answer is as follows:

In some crucial cases a NoSQL Database is considerably less expensive than a SQL Database, but a NoSQL Database cannot completely replace a SQL Database.

For example:

• Try to store millions of Media Files or other large Documents on a distributed RDBMS. Each document has to be quickly accessible and updatable.
• Try to create a very large dynamic key/value table as a replacement for an overgrown in-memory Hashmap.

Of course you can achieve this also with a relational database, but you will be faced with following problems:

• RDBMS BLOBS are slow. You can compensate this problem with database clustering but the typical workaround is to store a link or file-path and use the file system as data storage. In this case you always have to check for inconsistencies.
• You can create a key/value store in your SQL Database. But each access creates a heavy processing overhead. (Transaction handling, logging and versioning.)

NoSQL-Databases are optimized and designed to:

• Store and access large “binary” objects very fast.
• Accomplish fast data replication and use table separation (sharding) between different storages.
• They allow very fast key-value stores.

(Easy schema modification is often stated as NoSQL advantage, but I think this is also a trivial task with DDL.

– Don’t forget to set the initial value of the new column and enable the trigger after the table alteration. )

In contrast there are tasks you should use a SQL – Database:

• Data Presentation: In most cases visual entities (for example table lines and columns), aren’t 1:1 presentations from Database objects. They are sorted, mapped, reduced (filtered) and often consist of joins between different tables. Map-Reduce and sorting can be done efficiently with NoSQL. But joins aren’t supported. Of course you can rewrite the JOIN operation in your application. For example a simplified HashMap JOIN could look like this:

  var tableBMap : HashMap[idxType, Type of tableB] = tableB.foreach( line => tableBMap += (line.joinAttributB -> line))
  tableA.map( line => (line, tableBMap.get(line.joinAttributA)))

  The Disadvantage is, that you have to materialize the complete object / table-line.

• NoSQL = No Transaction. You cannot use NoSQL for reliable database transactions (reliable like in ACID). This is a serious restriction for massive parallel database updates. (Hence, you should avoid programming the popular Bank Account example with a NoSQL Database.)

Why I prefer MongoDB as NoSQL Database System:

• Very Fast: Sequential write and random read operations are done very fast on an “average” Server. (You need a 64 Bit OS if your database is larger than 2GB)
• Scala(Java) Support: Several drivers are available scamongo, mongo-scala-driver or akka-persistence
• Easy to use: There is no setup, parameter or table type “magic”. In less than an hour you can setup a secure and robust Database Server. The client uses JS/JSON.
• A nice community: The Forum is very active. Questions should be answered in a couple of hours.

Addendum to my recent Post: FSM stands for “Flying Spaghetti Monster”

In my recent post I used the abbreviation FSM for “Finite State Machine”.

I was informed that FSM is the common abbreviation for the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

I searched for this term in the Kungle News document-storage and found some evidence for this claim:

Here is the complete list of references:

Query:

Start Main

New Hist Defined with:

Primary: List(Flying Spaghetti Monster, Pastafarianism, Pastafarian)

Secondary in: List(FSM)

Secondary out: List()

Calculated Interval: { “publishingDate” : { “$gt” : “2010-01-10T23:00:00.000Z” , “$lte” : “2010-03-22T23:00:00.000Z”} , “originalLanguage” : “ENGLISH”}

…

Title	Published Recorded	Publisher	Citation
Mississippi dips its toe into antireality	Tue Jan 19 15:00:00 CET 2010	Discover Magazine	Finally they will spread the message of how we were all created by the Flying Spaghetti Monster
"Senator Webb (D) shows fear: ""Suspend All Votes On Health Care Bill Until Senator-Elect Brown Is Seated"""	Thu Jan 21 00:00:28 CET 2010	Crooks and Liars	it'll be approximately Dec 2012, slightly before she takes office, so I figure what better time for Jebus, Buddah, Allah, Ra, Flying Spaghetti Monster, the Mayans, The 'V' lizard people, the Vogons, Daleks, V'Ger, etc to arrive?
FSM protect us!	Tue Jan 26 19:40:17 CET 2010	Discover Magazine	Some people say the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster was a joke made ...
Video – Who Knew He Could Be A Swedish Hero?	Mon Feb 01 16:00:11 CET 2010	Dvorak Uncensored	I wonder if it will work with the Flying Spaghetti Monster?
Minority Contractors Receive Just 2 Percent of Highway Stimulus Cash	Thu Feb 04 20:31:08 CET 2010	Infrastructurist	What if only 2% of all infrastructure construction companies are women or minority owned? Setting a goal of having 10% of all contract recipients be minority or women owned is about as useful as setting a goal of having 10% of all contract recipients go to Wild Hildabeest and Flying Spaghetti Monster owned businesses.
When Did Jesus Become a Republican (or, for that matter, a Democrat?	Mon Feb 15 00:44:01 CET 2010	Care2 News	I'm a Pastafarian. To me it's the only pure religion.
Do we really need a religious bill of rights?	Mon Feb 15 15:27:14 CET 2010	Discover Magazine	If the act passes, we need a Pastafarian as an agent provocateur.
Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster FSM Store	Fri Feb 19 02:33:10 CET 2010	Suite101	Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster FSM Store
Iraq still embracing the magic	Wed Feb 24 02:02:34 CET 2010	Discover Magazine	No, just kidding, it’s “For Flying Spaghetti Monster’s Sake”
Miss Beverly Hills tries to one-up Carrie Prejean, says it’s divine law that gays be put to death.	Wed Feb 24 15:55:45 CET 2010	Think Progress	The Flying Spaghetti Monster offers more in life than any pagan based worship.
Video: Republican legislator says disabled children are 'God's punishment' for abortion	Wed Feb 24 19:00:09 CET 2010	Crooks and Liars	I think my Pastafarianism makes me less able to understand why so many people think a superior being gives a flying noodle what they do or say?
South Dakota legislators tell schools to teach ‘astrological’ explanation for global warming.	Thu Feb 25 19:49:40 CET 2010	Think Progress	All hail the Flying Spaghetti Monster!
"End of an Era: ""Lasts"" for Shuttle Program"	Fri Feb 26 18:32:36 CET 2010	Universe Today	Some spectacular pictures from the final SRB test. FSM-17, (that's flight support motor, not Flying Spaghetti Monster) burned for approximately 123 seconds — the same time each reusable solid rocket motor burns during an actual space shuttle launch.
Atheist Groups Visit The White House Causing A Right Wing Tizzy	Mon Mar 01 15:45:41 CET 2010	Dvorak Uncensored	(Before the religious start jumping up and down “See, atheists ARE a religion”, the whole thing is a joke, like the Flying Spaghetti Monster)
Creationists And Climate Deniers Take On Teaching Climate Science In Schools	Thu Mar 04 17:20:14 CET 2010	Huffingtonpost	I think we can all look forward to the time when these three theories are given equal time in our science classrooms across the country, and eventually the world; One third time for Intelligent Design, one third time for Flying Spaghetti Monsterism (Pastafarianism), and one third time for logical conjecture based on overwhelming observable evidence.
Massa Will Resign Monday	Fri Mar 05 20:43:18 CET 2010	Talking Points Memo	There is no doubt that there is a Flying Spaghetti Monster. The question is just how it flies, and what kind of sauce it's covered in.
ARD TV drama sparks Scientology's ire	Mon Mar 08 11:34:00 CET 2010	The Local Germany	What Would the Flying Spaghetti Monster Do?
Christian leaders urge Congress to ignore misinformation on abortion provisions and pass health reform.	Sat Mar 13 18:17:21 CET 2010	Think Progress	Since a Pastafarian, I will say RAmen. ;)
Kreutz Comet VIDEO: WATCH Newly-Discovered Comet's Collision Course With The Sun	Sun Mar 14 15:36:13 CET 2010	Huffingtonpost	It's the great noodly appendage of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.
"To The 9th Circuit Court Of Appeals, God Is ""Patriotic"" And No Longer ""Religious"""	Sun Mar 14 16:00:51 CET 2010	Crooks and Liars	I'd tell him to substitute Flying Spaghetti Monster where appropriate.
Boehner Claims Student Loan Reform Will ‘Eliminate Every Bank In The Country’	Fri Mar 19 23:42:19 CET 2010	Think Progress	The universe could have been created by a Flying Spaghetti Monster, or it could have always existed.

…

2; 0; 19

Topic Connections:

(fsm,1)(monster,1)(store,1)(flying,1)(church,1)(spaghetti,1)

Emotions:

(love,14)(hope,13) (+)/(-) (hate,7)(fear,7)

Public Tendency:

10; 5; 6

Country:

gb; us; no; cn; jp; in; se; au; ru; de; fr; ie; gr; nz; ca;

0; 20; 0; 0; 0; 0; 1; 0; 0; 0; 0; 0; 0; 0; 0;

Publisher Tendency:

(Discover Magazine,3)(Huffingtonpost,2)(The Local Germany,1)(Think Progress,0)(Talking Points Memo,-1)(Crooks and Liars,-3)

Calculation Done

Tags: database, MongoDB, NoSQL, Scala

This entry was posted on Wednesday, March 24th, 2010 at 10:34 am and is filed under Kungle News, Scala, database, development, english. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.